December 31, 2011

November 2011 Book Club "Little Bee" by Chris Cleave (Christmas Home Tour)

Hi Everyone,
 
What a beautiful Thanksgiving we were blessed with in Western Pennsylvania; I hope everyone enjoyed their holiday and the pleasantly warm November days. We even had a beautiful day for our book club’s annual Christmas Home Tour on November 19. Becky, Cheryl, Ginnie, Jody, Lori and I attended the tour as well as junior member, Kristen Barnhart, and my sister Theresa Beck.

Our tour included extravagant homes such as Doug Bell’s with a brick oven on a detached rotunda overlooking his wooded property and unique homes like Carol Foster’s with its antique baby-dolls, heirloom clothes, and furnishings. Highlighting our day was St. Paul’s Roman Catholic Church which featured stained glass windows handcrafted in Munich, Germany; exquisitely carved triptych altars, the first of their kind, designed to close during Holy Week; and flooring and altars constructed of marble from Conamara, Italy, inlaid with glass mosaics. We were shocked to learn that the total cost for the building and all its furnishings when it was completed 100 years ago was only $140,000! 

 In between our touring, we dined at the Hardwood Café on Rte. 8 and discussed our November book selection Little Bee by Chris Cleave.  The consensus on this title was not glowing. It was definitely not one of our best picks. For me, however, after reading this book, I have more of an understanding of the background of my friend from Nigeria, Sister Mercy. It’s deeply troubling that in so many parts of the world people think they have the right to persecute others. I can understand, now, why so many Nigerians like Sister Mercy become priests and nuns. It must be a prime opportunity to rise out of a horrible situation. As I listened to Little Bee share her stories, I could hear Sister Mercy recalling her own, “I am telling you…!” with her wide eyed expressions, “weh!”  

When I read a book, I always try to extract some bits of eternal wisdom, thoughts about human nature that are timeless, that apply to all generations. One of my favorites from Little Bee and one we discussed at the Hardwood Café was a remark made by the character Sarah’s mother to Sarah. She said, “One of you in a marriage has to be soft. One of you has to know how to say, Have it your way.” All of us could see in our own marriages which one is the “Have it your way” partner. Interestingly, we are now even seeing this eternal truth play out in our children’s relationships!
Also, I would like to note the narration of Cleave’s book, alternating first person. I thought it was a clever way to write the story, allowing the reader into the thoughts of both main characters. To become a New York Times Bestseller, I don’t think any other narration would have worked for Cleave’s story. The narration gave it a more biographical quality, and it kept the reader from becoming too opinionated about either Little Bee or Sarah. 

I really felt sorry for both characters, actually, especially at the end. Sarah should have been more cautious and less naïve about the volatile situation in Nigeria before jumping on the plane with Little Bee. Did anyone think that Lawrence planned the whole thing? On page 230 when Little Bee and Lawrence were in the park, before Charlie was missing, Little Bee said to Lawrence, “You should go back to them,” meaning his wife and children; Little Bee noted a “great sadness” that fell over Lawrence after she said this. Conveniently, Lawrence was the one who arranged for Sarah to board the plane. With his ties to Great Britain’s Home Security Office; I don’t believe he was helping Sarah as much as he was saving himself. Was he just acting as a desperate man? Think about it. He had everything to gain from deporting both Sarah and Little Bee, not only keeping his job but ultimately his wife and his children. Lawrence was a weak man; he saw his world falling apart and acted out of desperation. 

In closing our book club meeting at Hardwood Café, we set Friday evening, December 9, as the date for our book club Christmas party and Shakespeare’s Restaurant for our dinner. Please, let me know if you and your husband or a guest plan to attend so I can make enough reservations. Let’s meet at 5:00 PM at Appleby’s Restaurant/Bar on New Castle to start then we can carpool from there. This is a “dress for the holiday” affair so be festive! Most importantly, bring your “great” book ideas for January. We want the New Year to be filled with great reading!

Merry Christmas,
Tammy

P.S. Enclosed are the directions for Shakespeare’s Restaurant.

2020 Butler Women of Wisdom Book Club Annual Newsletter

BUTLER WOMEN OF WISDOM BOOK CLUB NEWSLETTER December 27, 2020 By Tammy C. Smith (Photo: Dawn breaks on Stoneybrook Drive in Saxonburg, Decem...