January 23, 2016

November 2015 Book Club "Beautiful Ruins" by Jess Walter





Reminder of Pasquale's Coastal Village; pic taken on our trip to Italy, 2011
Hi Everyone,

It was nice to see so many of you at the November meeting at Barb K.’s!  In attendance were Barb, of course, and Cheryl, Ginnie, Lori, Becky, Sharon, Mandy, and myself.  Eight in all! Barb’s home was a lovely venue for a relaxing meeting as we had expected. She served us a scrumptious pepperoni casserole, salad, and a yummy cake for dessert, mmmm good!  It is always enjoyable to share beautifully prepared food with good friends. 

The November meeting was extra special for another reason. As Cheryl lugged a huge box into Barb’s home, we all wondered what in God’s good name she had inside it. Mysteriously touting it as a “surprise,” we waited patiently for her to reveal its contents. Finally, at the end of our meeting, she opened the box and inside it were multiple hard-cover copies of Adriana Trigiani’s brand-new book All the Stars in the Heavens! Cheryl presented each of us with a personally signed edition from the author herself! Uh, ha, yes, the Butler Women of Wisdom, us! We are so excited to begin reading Trigiani’s next story for our January meeting. After reading Lucia, Lucia, Big Stone Gap, and The Shoemaker’s Wife, all three of which we loved; it will be fun to see how Trigiani spins another captivating tale with the Italian characters she has become so famously known for including in all of her books. (Many of us in our book club have a fondness for all things Italian!) So after leaving the Italian port of Cinque Terre in our November book Beautiful Ruins, we continue our Italian journey in All the Stars in the Heavens

Recalling Beautiful Ruins is like a maize.  The author Jess Walter had us hopping from character to character and from past to present within the lives of those characters.  The book was definitely a challenge for the mind as it required staying active not only with various personalities and time settings but also with multiple geographic locations.  I can’t begin to remember all of the places we traveled with Walter’s characters, but Italy and Hollywood were the hubs for most of the action. 

In Italy, Walter places us in Rome where Hollywood is filming the great epic Cleopatra, starring Richard Burton and Elizabeth Taylor. It makes for juicy reading when we are brought into Liz and Dick’s passionate affair, but most importantly, Dick’s philandering with another scrumptious beauty on the set, a young starlet named Dee Moray. Of course, Walters writes a dark Italian hero, Pasquale Tursi, into her story to save Dee’s honor as she meets with unfortunate circumstances resulting from her tryst with Dick. 

Protected in a peaceful Italian seaside village, we also learn of Pasquale’s own dark secret that weaves another tale of heartache along with Dick and Dee’s. And yet, within Pasquale’s story, we meet another character named Alvis Bender, an inebriated aspiring writer/car salesman, whose life fatefully intertwines twice with Dee Moray’s, first in Italy and later in the U.S.  

Click forward in time about 40 years to England and Pat, a dead head rock musician. As Pat recalls his spoiled rotten and disturbing youth, we have no sympathy for his recent bad breaks in the world of music. He is a user in more ways than one. It seems a sad roll of fate when we learn how Pat and Dee share a history. 

Still, on the other side of the globe, Walters continues introducing us to more characters, this time in Hollywood where Claire Silver, a young ambitious assistant to a film producer, and her boss the great producer himself, Michael Deane, soon share in Dick and Dee’s story.  But before we even begin to understand that connection, we must suffer the details of both Claire’s and Michael’s lives first. And just when we thought Walters had reached a cap on characters, she introduces Shane, a novice scriptwriter, whose story, let me be candid, has very little to do with anything.  Walters tries too hard to create characters, but forgets that characters need developed. However, just when we cannot begin to understand where Walters is leading us with her line-up of weak personalities, the pieces fall together and a plot emerges. 

All in all, Butler Women of Wisdom liked the book Beautiful Ruins. It was fun to have a sneak peek into the hidden world of Hollywood stars. We all remembered the scandal caused by the Liz and Dick affair! The two occupied newspaper and magazine headlines for years, and theirs was just one sordid story, out of thousands that will never be disclosed. That’s why our next book All the Stars in the Heavens is a delicious read. Trigiani creates a more realistic and beautifully written story that uncovers some of old Hollywood’s buried secrets.  Through the character of the famous Hollywood film star Loretta Young, we meet Hollywood’s most endearing stars of all times. I can’t wait to discuss this book with all of you, it is sure to be another Trigiani bestseller! I loved it!

Please join us at Natilie’s Pizzeria on Thursday, January 28, at 6 PM, for our next engaging meeting.  Let’s make it Hollywood night! I so enjoyed researching more on the film stars mentioned in Trigiani’s book, so why not do some homework? If each of us gathers some trivia on a favorite old film star from the 1930 era, we can all try and guess who it is! Bring a picture of them, too (phone pics allowed). Looking forward to seeing you all on Thursday!

Yours in reading,
Tammy

2020 Butler Women of Wisdom Book Club Annual Newsletter

BUTLER WOMEN OF WISDOM BOOK CLUB NEWSLETTER December 27, 2020 By Tammy C. Smith (Photo: Dawn breaks on Stoneybrook Drive in Saxonburg, Decem...